corrected copy sorry about some mistakes


Dear Dr Gomaa
DearDear Dr Wesam
Ms Abeer
Dear all members

Very many thanks for your ideas and contributions in GIS field. Acutally I find you touch the core area of GIS by discuss this idea. How do we teach to students and what????? In all European universities I thank there is a GIS subject but it is managed and taught in Geography Schools I mean geography school which has the degrees of GIS (Msc or PhD)
Builds a good and complete Hardware and Software firstly and it should has a clusters or complete workshop or geographer staff. Every Dr in GIS filed in geography school has interested in one area, for instance, one Dr for statistical method, another one for healthcare, another for GIS and population, another one for GIS and Crimes, another for planning in Urban, another for programming, another for remote sensing and etc .....

GIS here like a body every Dr has interested in one area just one area, so you can realize that a professor who is first one or second all over the world in his subject but he or she has interested in one area. Iam not support geography and neglect other interesting science but the fact that GIS has a basic role or concept that spatial idea is the basement where GIS appears in a perfect character on it. In other words, without spatial features and place we can not understand what GIS is? Let me give another example from here in Britain, one module about planning there have been 5 Drs teach this module every one has taught one subject in his GIS area where he or she got his PhD

A good system for GIS Dear requires a good system for geography firstly without that we can not talk about any progress. Because in any school where there are degrees in GIS, there are Drs who teach GIS must got Msc (Master of Science and PhD in GIS we do not see any Dr from another subject.
The most important issue is GIS applications, I mean each subject has a spatial character should have GIS application why? Because we have to solve our problems in our societies. Another meaning, do not learn GIS for fun.GIS a tool ((methodology) and approaches (literature review) can solve any problem if we tend to use it correctly!!!!?? are there evidences about this saying? yes, of course, every GIS Drs here has a main project and fund from agency, organization, company, what ever comes outside the university.

For the Master program of Emart university, good and developed based on complete structure, but it divides GIS to many places and subjects. Dr Gomaa, I hope to accept this opinion from your student, we should develop human source firstly before build the GIS plan. Who will be teaching and where?? They have to have good certificates and training in theory and practice

If I work effectively with ARC GIS but there no application, scientific papers and publication I think I am like who has water but is not able to give it to thirsty people close to him.

I have never supported the idea that GIS has not a scientific frame or theory. Shall we prompt a GIS for scientific applications? Our societies have many problems with incorrect investigations. We have to encourage the main idea that GIS is a one body In our school of geography there are many students from other colleges come every day to attend the GIS lectures Example,


IT, Environment, and Public health colleges. why this happens because a GIS is one unit in one place where spatial science is found . On the other hand, I support that GIS in one place one college will be more efficient than otherwise. I suggest that from a vital experience I live and love it every day. Please, take care, if geography in our societies has not the right position, GIS will not improved
.

Imagine that Geography is an idea which is related to capital countries names {this famous saying in Arabian countries so maker decisions have not put Geography in the right place} do think that GIS will be a good subject in this society?

I appreciate that there are many and lot cleaver and scientists people from another subject but they have learnt in Geography College and some of them work in Geography colleges. Dr Wesam is not geographer but he has published in Geography College
Alex Uni and I attended this conference when he explains his paper.

Finally GIS unit could be in another place far way from Geography College and it would be successful but this will not happen
Without geographers who got degrees and training in GIS {please don't say that I am bigot for geography because I discuss the idea [U]that where we have to teach GIS NOT where GIS should be)